In the era of popular TV shows like Hell’s Kitchen or Masterchef, the cook profession is gaining more and more recognition.

We can witness the best of the best efforts whenever we like, wondering: Would I be qualified to do that too? Well, not everyone is born for this exact career. But everyone can try their hand at Overcooked!

This series of cooking simulation video games from Ghost Town Games is gaining more and more fans. Challenging, fun, connecting people, and revealing the nature of working in a professional kitchen. A kitchen that floats at sea or gets attacked by demons. Wondering which Overcooked part you should buy? Here is a guide prepared just for you. Welcome to the ultimate Overcooked or Overcooked 2 comparison!

You can find Cooking Games Deals on G2A.COM.

Key differences between Overcooked and Overcooked 2

FeatureOvercookedOvercooked 2
Storyline Save the Onion Kingdom from culinary disaster. Defend the Onion Kingdom from an ancient evil.
Levels & Recipes Original levels and recipes. New levels, new recipes, and moving kitchen elements.
Item Throwing Not available. Players can throw ingredients across the kitchen.
Multiplayer Mode Local multiplayer only. Online multiplayer allows global competition and cooperation.
Difficulty Level More challenging and competitive. Easier, more casual gameplay experience.

General overview

Both titles are cooking sim video games focused on cooperation where four heroes can face a series of challenging culinary tasks. The gameplay is part of a larger story in which the diverse kitchens of the mighty Onion Kingdom fight for victory. The heroes must undertake the task of preparing the most excellent dishes to delight their guests and score as many points as possible. This way, they will move to the following levels and so on.

Official Trailer of Overcooked Game, Youtube@Team17

The game is set in a colorful and humorous atmosphere, making it a perfect recommendation for an evening with a loved one at home or a party with friends. It is also great for kids who have the opportunity to compete with adults! As for the mechanics – this one is easier than the execution itself.

Players follow precise recipes that they have to complete. The order and pace are the most crucial factors in this game. Everything can go wrong here! Impatient customers, burning pots and plates, dirty moves of the opposing team, and numerous traps. Chaos and mayhem! Sounds like fun? So let’s decide the ultimate game for you.

The main differences

Both games are nearly similar, but after a while of gameplay, you will discover that Overcooked II has implemented some changes. Is it for the better? Let’s find out!

A big novelty is, above all, entirely new levels and recipes. Players have to deal with many moving elements and ensure all guests are satisfied. Moreover, Overcooked II tells a slightly different story of the Onion Kingdom, where Onion King unleashes an ancient evil that seeks the destruction of all humanity. It is another chance to become a hero!

One of the main differences is throwing items all over the kitchen. You can toss the ingredients into your pot, into another player’s pot, or throw it across the length of the kitchen, only to see how far you are throwing. It is an enormous help in the challenging cooking process as you still have to take care of the remaining dishes and make sure the pots are clean.

What else? Unlike Overcooked 1, the second part introduced the online multiplayer. It significantly diversifies the gameplay, as you can cooperate or compete with total random players from around the world! It is your chance to experience an entirely unpredictable adventure in the world of Overcooked.

Co-op in Overcooked 2, Youtube@Team17

Which should you buy?

When deciding between Overcooked and Overcooked II, it ultimately depends on what you’re looking for in a game.

Although Overcooked seems to score better at this comparison, let’s check what the others have to say about it. The feedback from many players on Steam or Reddit confirms some patterns about the mechanics of both parts. And it turns out that Overcooked II is much easier than the first part.

So easy, it’s downright frustrating. Kitchen competition fans may be disappointed with the Overcooked II difficulty level, especially if they’ve already dealt with part one. It is a proposition for those who want to have fun without focusing too much on the gameplay.

FAQ

Is Overcooked 2 better than Overcooked?

Many players find Overcooked 2 better due to new features like online multiplayer, throwing mechanics, and more varied levels. However, some still prefer the simplicity of the original.

Is Overcooked 2 harder than 1?

Overcooked 2 is generally considered easier than the first game, thanks to new mechanics like the ability to throw ingredients, which can make completing levels more manageable.

Is Overcooked: All You Can Eat the same as Overcooked 1 and 2?

Overcooked: All You Can Eat is a remastered collection that includes both Overcooked 1 and 2, along with all DLC and new content, plus updated graphics and features.

Conclusion

Both Overcooked and Overcooked 2 are excellent choices depending on your preferences. If you’re looking for a more challenging and competitive experience, the original Overcooked is the way to go. However, if you prefer a more casual, feature-rich game with the ability to play online, Overcooked 2 is likely a better fit. Either way, both games offer a delightful and chaotic culinary adventure that’s well worth the investment.

References